Hemisphere
Development LLC | Consulting
CASE STUDY: Collinwood

COLLINWOOD YARDS RECOVERS FROM 20 YEARS OF BLIGHT
Once
it was the most active railyard linking the industrial centers
of the Midwest and Northeast. But since 1980, the abandoned 47-acre
Collinwood Locomotive Rail Car Maintenance Facility, known as
Collinwood Yards, had served only as a sad reminder of the long-faded
glory of the nation's railroads. More importantly to potential
investors and developers, industrial activities at the site since
1873 had left it with significant unresolved environmental issues.
A
Catalyst for Community Redevelopment
For 20 years, Collinwood Yards sat vacant at its location approximately
six miles east of downtown Cleveland, Ohio. In 1982, Conrail sold
the property to private investors who were unsuccessful in their
efforts to generate interest from small manufacturers or commercial
tenants. The site's environmental problems included underground
storage tanks, heavy oils and greases in soil and groundwater,
asbestos and lead paint in dilapidated buildings and PCBs in old
equipment. Early environmental studies indicated that the costs
of cleaning up the site would be prohibitive for anyone who might
have wanted to use or redevelop the property.
In
the mid-1990s, the city of Cleveland asked a national panel of
experts from the Urban Land Institute to recommend land-use strategies
that would benefit the Collinwood community. The report identified
Collinwood Yards as the catalyst that would lead to the redevelopment
of the rest of the community. The current owner retained Hemisphere
to lead the effort of cleaning up and redeveloping the site in
a timely and cost-effective manner. Hemisphere was responsible
for coordinating all environmental work, negotiating regulatory
issues with state officials, securing low-interest public financing
and implementing a public relations program.
New Solutions to an Old Problem
Hemisphere helped assemble a mix of city and state grants, low-interest
loans, tax abatement and private investment to finance a $15 million
redevelopment project for Collinwood Yards. The site also received
an Urban Setting Designation from the state of Ohio because it
was shown that residents would not be using groundwater for drinking,
showering, bathing or cooking. Absent the need for groundwater
remediation, cleanup costs were dramatically reduced to about
$2 million, much less than the $20 million to $30 million estimated
by the original environmental studies. Grants from Ohio's Urban
and Rural Initiative Grant Program and Cleveland's Neighborhood
Development Investment Fund covered the cleanup costs. Within
nine months of its original engagement, Hemisphere secured a "Covenant
Not to Sue" for the site from the Ohio Environmental Protection
Agency.
Cleanup
Attracts New Interest
That Covenant enabled Jergens Inc., a hardware manufacturing company,
to purchase 13 acres at the site for a new 90,000-square-foot
manufacturing facility. The facility, which generated approximately
150 full-time jobs, is part of a 47-acre industrial park planned
for Collinwood Yards. Seventeen acres of the property were purchased
by CSX Transportation for a new intermodal transfer facility,
which is expected to create several hundred jobs and restore the
site's status as a premier transportation hub. The Collinwood
Yards redevelopment was a finalist in the 1999 Phoenix Award competition
for the best brownfield project in U.S. EPA Region 5 and designated
by the Urban Land Institute as a National Showcase Brownfield.